Chronicles of Charlotte



Completed April 2023

NEVADA

IMOGEN BINNIE

Not only did this book refuse to follow the rules, at times it didn't even acknowledge them. I get the sense this fact will divide opinions. But beneath all the bravado, there was sensitivity too.

I started Nevada unaware of how little I understood gender dysphoria (something I am lucky enough to not to have experienced) and I came away feeling both educated and moved. Saying this, the story was definitely presented as the indefinite article – a trans experience rather than the trans experience – a fact which I think worked in its favour, giving the story a level of specificity and therefore authenticity which verged on autobiographical.

For this reason, the choice of third person perspective was intriguing. The narrative was so skewed towards the inner monologue that first person would have been a far more obvious choice, but instead we experienced the two protagonists' thoughts and feelings from the outside in. This almost created a sense of distrust, as if, despite their raw honesty, a wall remained. At times, this verged on uncomfortable, as if as a reader I was intruding in a perspective that had never been intentionally shared.

This made it difficult reading at times, especially due to the intimacy of the confessions. Maria's description of disassociation was viscerally shocking, as she oscillated between sharp and engaged and totally zoned out. Her situation could have been easily dismissed as cliche: a queer nearly-30-year-old living in NYC and working in retail, with tumultuous relationships and no clear ambitions. At first, this stereotype rubbed me up the wrong way, but as the story developed it became clear how she'd found herself in such a position. To achieve this insight we needed to switch perspective – to James, who was currently in a predicament similar to that Maria had escaped from.

Through their plot lines colliding we learned that her chaotic mindset was a result of the both the trauma she'd undergone and the interminable difficulties she still faced just to exist in the world. Her continuous projections of indifference were in fact a defence mechanism, a realisation she admitted to both herself and to James, whose future was thrown into question by this one interaction.

Maria's mentorship wasn't straightforward however. Their experiences were highly individual, and despite her best intentions the applicability of her advice was questionable – especially as James bristled against it. It didn't help that neither character was particularly likeable, and by the end of the novel neither had achieved a great level of personal growth.

Portraying each narrator as, in both of their words, 'messed up', without hesitation or apology was a powerful move, and one that reflected the overall attitude of the book. Would it have been a technically better story (and would the characters have been more socially accepted individuals) if more consideration had been invested in the comfort of others? Maybe so, maybe not.

Personally, I'm glad it wasn't, as tying up the story with a nice bow would have felt too simplistic. In reality, gender is complex, and in my opinion authenticity beats sentimentality every time.

“I’m sorry, she always thinks, I learned to police myself pretty fiercely when I was a tiny little baby, internalizing social norms and trying to keep myself safe from them at the same time.”

Return to library






Website design + code by Charlotte Stapleton